Gavel and scales of justice

In the ongoing Engle tobacco litigation case, Bernice McCall asserts that Philip Morris, the defendant, deliberately obscured the hazards of cigarettes, leading to the development of lung cancer and the subsequent passing of Martin McCall.

Empathy and Justice: Michael Alvarez Secures $475k in Punitive Damages for Client in Philip Morris USA Inc. v. McCall

In the legal arena, some cases stand out not just for their complexity but for the profound impact they can have on individuals' lives. Philip Morris USA Inc. v. McCall is one such case that delves into the heart-wrenching consequences of smoking and the responsibility of tobacco companies. In a landmark victory, Michael Alvarez of The Alvarez Law Firm secured $475,000 in punitive damages for our client, offering a glimmer of justice in the face of tragedy.

The Backdrop: McCall's Pursuit of Justice

At the core of this legal saga is a grieving widow, the plaintiff, who filed suit against Philip Morris (PM) after losing her husband to lung cancer allegedly caused by the addiction to cigarettes manufactured and marketed by the company. The plaintiff, represented by Michael Alvarez, took a multi-faceted legal approach, alleging strict liability, fraud by concealment, conspiracy to commit fraud by concealment, and negligence.

The Legal Landscape: Unraveling the Evidence

The legal battleground in this case revolves around the Engle case, where the plaintiff argued that her deceased husband fell within the Engle class. This class, established in previous tobacco litigation, involves individuals who suffered harm due to smoking.

The case proceeded to a two-phase trial. In the first phase, the jury scrutinized evidence concerning the deceased's smoking history, illness, and eventual demise. The plaintiff's presentation included poignant details of the decedent's lifelong smoking habits, influenced by misleading advertisements that touted filtered cigarettes as "safe."

Expert testimony underscored the tobacco companies' alleged knowledge of the addictive nature of nicotine and the harmful effects of smoking, portraying a fifty-year history of obfuscation and marketing strategies aimed at encouraging smoking.

The second phase of the trial, reserved for determining punitive damages, proved equally noteworthy. Michael Alvarez's advocacy culminated in a remarkable $475,000 in punitive damages awarded to our client, sending a powerful message about accountability in tobacco industry cases.

A Victory for Justice and Empathy

Philip Morris USA Inc. v. McCall exemplifies the intersection of legal acumen, empathy, and the pursuit of justice. Through meticulous legal strategy and unwavering dedication, Michael Alvarez navigated the complexities of Engle class claims and secured a significant win for our client through punitive damages. In this landmark case, justice prevailed, offering solace to those affected by the devastating consequences of tobacco-related illnesses.

Back to Blog

Let’s talk about your case.

Schedule a Consultation
Contact us media